EA Reviews: every ATS EA in one dashboard

The Gold Reaper

ATSProfalgo LTD

4.5

4.5

The Gold Reaper by Profalgo is the best gold EA our scouting audit has found so far: 2 years of public live signal with independently verified +271% at a 16.9% max drawdown and PF 2.38 — a clean stop-loss approach instead of a grid. Why we still say “watch” rather than “buy”.

Aussie Victor EA

ATSTickStack

4.2

4.2

Aussie Victor is a grid EA on a single pair (AUDCAD) with ML-entry marketing. The advertised low drawdown (6.78%) is attractive — but unverified by us and typical of a grid's smooth equity curve right up until it isn't. Why we say “with reservations” and what the ATS calibration changes about that.

Forex Fury

ATSForex Fury

4.2

4.2

scalping on AUDNZD/AUDUSD/EURCHF by Forex Fury. Verified account, max floating loss -2,0 % — calmly run.

Dark Nova

ATSDark EAs

4.1

4.1

grid/scalping on AUDCAD/AUDNZD/NZDCAD by Dark EAs. Verified account, max floating loss -10,0 % — calmly run.

Global Trade Plan EA

ATSMeetAlgo

4.1

4.1

trend-following on XAUUSD by MeetAlgo. Verified account, max floating loss -2,3 % — calmly run.

Prime Scalper EA

ATSMeetAlgo

4.1

4.1

Prime Scalper by MeetAlgo is the most positive find of this round: +50.1% over 258 days at only -2.6% max floating loss and PF 1.32 on 214 trades — a scalper with a strikingly small risk footprint and no visible grid blow-up pattern. On top of that it is cheap (under €100). The caution stays: scalping is spread- and latency-dependent (a raw-spread broker + VPS are mandatory), and 258 days is not yet a full cycle.

Prop Firm Robots App

ATS

4.1

4.1

trend-following. Verified account, max floating loss -2,8 % — calmly run.

WallStreet Recovery Pro

ATSFX Automater

4.1

4.1

grid on EURUSD/GBPUSD/USDJPY by FX Automater. Verified account, max floating loss -7,7 % — calmly run.

ATS Origin Portfolio

ATSAlgo Trading Space

4.0

4.0

The Origin Portfolio is AlgoTradingSpace's own multi-pair grid bundle — four EAs across five forex pairs, built in-house in EA Studio. The trust anchor is not the “Low Risk" marketing tag but the fact that ATS runs the portfolio live on its own account under a fixed risk cap. We hold no independent live track of our own — which is why we stay cautious.

Dark Gold EA

ATSDark EAs

4.0

4.0

trend-following on BTCUSD/XAUUSD by Dark EAs. Verified account, max floating loss -8,7 % — calmly run.

Forex Gold Investor

ATSFX Automater

4.0

4.0

grid/trend-following on XAUUSD by FX Automater. Verified account, max floating loss -15,0 %.

FXConstant

ATSForex Store

4.0

4.0

grid on AUDUSD/EURUSD by Forex Store. Verified account, max floating loss -5,4 % — calmly run.

Gold Scalper Pro

ATSFX Automater

4.0

4.0

Gold Scalper Pro by FX Automater scalps XAUUSD with a fixed stop-loss and take-profit — defined risk per trade instead of a grid basket, and that is exactly what lifts it above the grid crowd. The downsides: scalping is extremely spread- and latency-sensitive (a raw-spread broker + low-latency VPS are mandatory), and XAUUSD correlates with every other gold EA. We hold no independent live track.

Happy Gold EA

ATSHappy Forex

4.0

4.0

scalping/swing on XAUUSD by Happy Forex. Verified account, max floating loss -17,6 %.

Neural Nexus EA

ATSForex Store

4.0

4.0

Neural Nexus is a mean-reversion grid marketed as a “Beginner” EA — and that is the contradiction: mean-reversion grids feel calm and then take a large loss. Why “Beginner” plus grid needs a hard cap, and what the vendor-house context (Forex Store) adds to the picture.

FX Proctor Max EA

ATSForex Store

3.9

3.9

trend-following on AUDUSD/EURUSD/USDCAD by Forex Store. Verified account, max floating loss -10,9 % — calmly run.

Architect Algo EA

ATSResponsible Forex Trading

3.8

3.8

grid/intraday on AUDCAD/AUDCHF/AUDJPY by Responsible Forex Trading. Martingale/grid — only with a hard risk cap.

Dark Titan

ATSDark EAs

3.8

3.8

grid/martingale on AUDCAD/AUDNZD/NZDCAD by Dark EAs. Martingale/grid — only with a hard risk cap.

Dark Venus EA

ATSDark EAs

3.8

3.8

grid/martingale on AUDCAD/AUDNZD/EURGBP by Dark EAs. Martingale/grid — only with a hard risk cap.

Happy Index EA

ATS

3.8

3.8

trend-following. Verified account, max floating loss -20,5 %.

Market Fighter EA

ATSForex Store

3.8

3.8

grid/trend-following on EURUSD/USDCHF/USDJPY by Forex Store. Verified account, max floating loss -25,4 %.

Perceptrader AI EA

ATSValery Trading

3.8

3.8

trend-following on AUDCAD/AUDNZD/GBPCHF by Valery Trading. Verified account, max floating loss -9,6 % — calmly run.

Waka Waka EA

ATSValery Trading

3.8

3.8

Waka Waka is one of the longest-lived grid EAs on the MQL5 market: 8+ years of public live signal and above-average vendor transparency — but a grid/averaging core with the tail risk that implies, at a $2,800 price tag. We run it live ourselves and break down who it is (not) for.

Forex Trend Hunter EA

ATSFX Automater

3.7

3.7

trend-following on EURJPY/EURUSD/GBPJPY by FX Automater. Verified account, max floating loss -47,8 %.

Dark Algo EA

ATSDark EAs

3.6

3.6

grid/martingale on EURUSD/GBPUSD by Dark EAs. Martingale/grid — only with a hard risk cap.

Happy Forex EA

ATSHappy Forex

3.6

3.6

grid/swing on AUDUSD/EURCHF/EURUSD by Happy Forex. Verified account, max floating loss -31,0 %.

Infinity Trader EA

ATSFX Automater

3.6

3.6

grid on AUDCAD/GBPUSD/NZDCAD by FX Automater. ⚠ Verified account, but max floating loss -50,7 % — blow-up risk.

Dark Dione EA

ATSDark EAs

3.5

3.5

grid/trend-following on CHFJPY/EURUSD/GBPUSD by Dark EAs. ⚠ Verified account, but max floating loss -63,6 % — blow-up risk.

Dark Rea EA

ATSDark EAs

3.5

3.5

intraday/trend-following on AUDUSD/EURCHF/EURUSD by Dark EAs. ATS-vetted; no publicly linked live account — rating from strategy audit.

Happy Frequency EA

ATSHappy Forex

3.5

3.5

grid/trend-following on AUDUSD/EURCHF/EURGBP by Happy Forex. Verified account, max floating loss -41,5 %.

Market Master EA

ATSMarket Master

3.5

3.5

trend-following on EURUSD by Market Master. ⚠ Verified account, but max floating loss -66,1 % — blow-up risk.

News Scope EA Pro

ATSFX Automater

3.5

3.5

intraday/scalping on AUDUSD/EURUSD/GBPUSD by FX Automater. ATS-vetted; no publicly linked live account — rating from strategy audit.

RFP Gold V5

ATS

3.5

3.5

Trading robot. ATS-vetted; no publicly linked live account — rating from strategy audit.

Alpha Hype Forex EA

ATSRobot Forex Pro

3.4

3.4

grid/trend-following on EURUSD by Robot Forex Pro. ATS-vetted; no publicly linked live account — rating from strategy audit.

Dark Mimas EA

ATSDark EAs

3.4

3.4

grid/scalping on AUDCAD/AUDCHF/EURUSD by Dark EAs. ATS-vetted; no publicly linked live account — rating from strategy audit.

Dark Moon EA

ATSDark EAs

3.4

3.4

grid/scalping on EURUSD/GBPUSD/NZDUSD by Dark EAs. ATS-vetted; no publicly linked live account — rating from strategy audit.

EasyAI Grid EA

ATSValery Trading

3.4

3.4

grid on AUDCAD/AUDNZD/GBPCHF by Valery Trading. ATS-vetted; no publicly linked live account — rating from strategy audit.

Forex Diamond EA

ATSFX Automater

3.4

3.4

grid on EURUSD/GBPUSD/USDCHF by FX Automater. ATS-vetted; no publicly linked live account — rating from strategy audit.

Forex Enigma EA

ATS

3.4

3.4

trend-following on EURCHF. ATS-vetted; no publicly linked live account — rating from strategy audit.

Forex inControl 3.0 EA

ATS

3.4

3.4

trend-following on AUDUSD/EURGBP. ATS-vetted; no publicly linked live account — rating from strategy audit.

Forex Truck Turbo EA

ATS

3.4

3.4

trend-following on EURGBP/EURUSD/GBPUSD. ATS-vetted; no publicly linked live account — rating from strategy audit.

FXStabilizer PRO EA

ATSForex Store

3.4

3.4

trend-following on AUDUSD/CHFJPY/EURGBP by Forex Store. ATS-vetted; no publicly linked live account — rating from strategy audit.

Happy Algorithm PRO EA

ATSHappy Forex

3.4

3.4

trend-following on EURUSD/USDCHF by Happy Forex. ATS-vetted; no publicly linked live account — rating from strategy audit.

Happy Breakout EA

ATSHappy Forex

3.4

3.4

trend-following on EURUSD/GBPJPY/GBPUSD by Happy Forex. ATS-vetted; no publicly linked live account — rating from strategy audit.

Happy Japanese Market EA

ATSHappy Forex

3.4

3.4

trend-following on EURJPY/GBPJPY/USDJPY by Happy Forex. ATS-vetted; no publicly linked live account — rating from strategy audit.

Happy Neuron EA

ATSHappy Forex

3.4

3.4

trend-following on AUDCAD/AUDCHF/AUDJPY by Happy Forex. ATS-vetted; no publicly linked live account — rating from strategy audit.

Sharpshooter EA Expert Advisor

ATSResponsible Forex Trading

3.4

3.4

trend-following on EURUSD/GBPUSD by Responsible Forex Trading. ATS-vetted; no publicly linked live account — rating from strategy audit.

Evening Scalper Pro EA

ATSValery Trading

3.3

3.3

trend-following on AUDCAD/AUDNZD/EURAUD by Valery Trading. ATS-vetted; no publicly linked live account — rating from strategy audit.

Golden Pickaxe EA

ATSValery Trading

3.3

3.3

trend-following on XAUUSD by Valery Trading. ATS-vetted; no publicly linked live account — rating from strategy audit.

News Catcher Pro EA

ATSValery Trading

3.3

3.3

intraday on EURGBP/EURUSD/GBPUSD by Valery Trading. ATS-vetted; no publicly linked live account — rating from strategy audit.

Night Hunter Pro EA

ATSValery Trading

3.3

3.3

trend-following on AUDCAD/AUDJPY/CHFJPY by Valery Trading. ATS-vetted; no publicly linked live account — rating from strategy audit.

PoundX Expert Advisor

ATSMultiForex

3.3

3.3

grid/intraday on GBPUSD by MultiForex. ATS-vetted; no publicly linked live account — rating from strategy audit.

Happy MartiGrid EA

ATSHappy Forex

3.2

3.2

grid/martingale on AUDUSD/EURJPY/EURUSD by Happy Forex. ATS-vetted; no publicly linked live account — rating from strategy audit.

Ranger EA

ATSResponsible Forex Trading

3.2

3.2

grid/martingale on AUDCAD/GBPCAD by Responsible Forex Trading. ATS-vetted; no publicly linked live account — rating from strategy audit.

Ultimate Breakout System

MQL5Profalgo Limited

3.2

3.2

A configurable breakout framework from the established Profalgo team with 100+ set files; it is the building block the Gold Reaper is built on and discloses a conservative drawdown profile. The red flag is less the substance than the price (~$1,499–1,999) against a still-young live record — you buy a toolkit, not a finished track. Our audit: yellow, 62/100.

Vigorous EA

ATSResponsible Forex Trading

3.2

3.2

grid/martingale on EURUSD by Responsible Forex Trading. ATS-vetted; no publicly linked live account — rating from strategy audit.

Happy Crude Oil

ATSHappy Forex

3.1

3.1

Happy Crude Oil trades WTI crude via a grid on M5 — rated High-Risk by the vendor itself. It is interesting solely because of the instrument: oil is a genuine decorrelator to forex and gold. But a high-risk grid on one of the most volatile markets around is only defensible with a hard risk cap and a tiny allocation. Not a core holding — at best a satellite.

Quantum StarMan

ATSValery Trading

3.0

3.0

Quantum StarMan is one of the most expensive robots in the ATS catalog (from €1,000) — a grid system on multiple majors by Valery Trading. The advertised “precision and risk controls” are vendor claims we cannot verify. Why a four-figure price for an unproven grid basket earns a conservative rating from us.

Smart Gold Hunter

MQL5Barbaros Bulent Kortarla

3.0

3.0

A cheap gold EA ($250) without grid or martingale, with a modest profit factor (~1.35) and visible losing trades — a healthier signature than rivals' 'perfect' curves. The red flag is the short history: 100%+ in only ~4 months at <5% DD is exactly the 'too good' profile that still has to hold over a longer window; the review average has also slipped from all-5-star to 4.1 (58).

Twister Pro

MQL5Jorge Luiz Guimaraes De Araujo Dias

3.0

3.0

A gold scalper (H1) that explicitly runs no grid and no martingale and closes every trade with a defined TP/SL; the live signals run cleanly with low drawdown and no deposit cosmetics. The red flag is the backtest: profit factor, Sharpe and ~80% win rate are too perfect and smell of overfitting — the live evidence carries more here than the curve. Fairly priced at $399.

Dark Kronos

ATSDark EAs

2.9

2.9

Dark Kronos by Dark EAs posts +80.7% over 241 days on the calibrated ATS live account — alongside a maximum floating loss of -74.7%. Translated: the account was at one point almost three-quarters underwater (open). That is the grid tail risk, realised live here, not just in a backtest. PF 5.29 is the smooth-curve illusion, right up until a basket runs. Nothing for small accounts, and only with a hard cap.

Lizard

MQL5Marco Scherer

2.9

2.9

A gold scalper that shows its drawdown (~33%) openly in both live signal and backtest and opens the product page with a risk warning — transparency is the plus here, a large gain next to a large DD is more honest than an unrealistically smooth curve. Red flag: the price was hiked to $999 after a drawdown period drew negative reviews — expensive for a heavy risk profile.

Adaptive Gold Scalper

MQL5Fan Yang

2.7

2.7

An MA-crossover scalper on gold and Nasdaq 100 with several genuine live signals at reputable brokers (TMGM, Tickmill, Vantage) — these show large drawdowns but also 100%+ months. The red flag is the discrepancy: the backtest comes in at only ~1% DD with a tripled account, which next to the heavy live DDs looks like curve fitting. As a tight-stop scalper it strictly needs a low-cost, tight-spread broker.

Quantum King

MQL5Bogdan Ion Puscasu

2.5

2.5

The only non-gold candidate: a mean-reversion grid on AUDCAD — a sensible pairing of strategy to a mean-reverting instrument — with 253 reviews and moderate monthly returns. Red flag: independent sources describe it as a grid PLUS adaptive martingale recovery, the live signal shows balance top-ups and a real ~25-30% DD. The blow-up risk is higher than the calm monthly numbers suggest.

Scalping Robot Pro

MQL5MQL TOOLS SL

2.2

2.2

Strong on paper: ~#3 best-seller with 4.4/152 reviews and a $600 price. The red flag and reason for red: the live signal is disabled and the previous one was replaced by a fresh signal — there is no continuous public track against which the reviews could be verified, and the backtest is 'too good to be true'. No verifiable live proof, no trust.

Quantum Queen X

MQL5Bogdan Ion Puscasu

2.1

2.1

Successor to the discontinued Quantum Queen from the top seller on the MQL5 charts, published on 2026-07-14 — four days after a buyer's public case study on the gold event. Red flag: the page advertises a 'signal with over 28 months' — that history belongs to the predecessor product, not to X. A gold grid the seller labels himself, with no stated stop-loss; our audit: red, 43/100.

Quantum iGold

MQL5Yassine Mouhssine

1.9

1.9

A brand-new gold M15 EA (published 2026-07-11) from a no-name seller with under 500 sales that reached the top of the market by unclear means. The red flags bundle together: NO live signal, a backtest with profit factor ~48, Sharpe ~31 and a ~96-97% win rate with essentially no losses — the classic overfit/manipulation signature. The 'Quantum' name borrows Bogdan's branding but is not his product.