Skip to content
AlgoVerdict
Menu
One Man Army product shot

EA review ·

One Man Army

One Man Army

2 signals on real-money accounts (per MQL5 rules), selected by the vendor

The vendor lists 2 public signals. We checked that they exist and can be viewed. The seller still chooses what to show, so such evidence earns at most 8.0 for verifiability.

Checked
Signal exists and is public · real money per the MQL5 signal rules, broker’s live server · trading behaviour matches the described design
Not shown
Return, drawdown, running time. Past figures tempt buyers more than they inform them.
Counts towards
Verifiability (25% of the grade): 7.4 out of 10
Strength of evidence
2 of 3: selected by the seller
Mean reversion8 marketsMT5

Reviewed by Pitt Petruschke, operator. No stake in One Man Army; receives commission from ATS and develops his own EA, Dawnbreak. Disclosure

Cross-checked by an AI agent (different model, blind): 5 of 6 criteria agree. Differences

Verdict

Solid evidence with a stop-loss per trade and two signals over more than a year, but a significant drawdown, long sideways phases, additional entries in the Double Shot signal despite “no averaging”, and prop firm claims without proof.

One Man Army by Ihor Otkydach is a forex EA for MT5 that trades reversals on 17 pairs on M15 with limit orders, each trade with a stop-loss. It costs $599 on the MQL5 market (as of 17 Nov 2026). Two public signals from the vendor have run for over a year at two brokers. They show a significant drawdown and, since late summer 2026, a flat to falling phase. The prop firm marketing is not backed by any account.

Suits you if …

  • Yes: you want an EA with fixed entries and exits
  • Yes: you run it as one building block in a portfolio
  • Caution: you set setfile and risk yourself, without ATS calibration

Design & risk

One Man Army by Ihor Otkydach is a Mean reversion EA on AUDCAD, GBPCAD, NZDCAD, EURAUD (MT5), sold on the MQL5 market. Each position has its own exit; losses are not absorbed by averaging in. What matters is whether execution at your broker matches the described process. You buy the vendor default; risk frame and setfile are up to you.

Newsletter · Sundays

New EA reviews, by email on Sundays

Before you buy your next EA: once a week, the digest brings the new and updated reviews.

  • New EA reviews with grade and verdict
  • What changed in existing verdicts
  • A note when something material changes on a signal we track

By subscribing you agree to receive the digest by email. You confirm via a link (double opt-in) and can unsubscribe anytime via the link in every email. Details in the privacy policy.

The full review

Overview

One Man Army by Ihor Otkydach (brand Intradaysoft) is a forex EA that bets on reversals rather than breakouts: it places limit orders in zones where it expects a correction and protects every trade with a stop. Unlike many new EAs, there is more than a year of live data on two signals. They show a good first half of 2026, a significant drawdown and, since late summer, a flat to falling phase. On top of that come a contradiction on additional entries and prop firm marketing that no account backs up.

What the vendor sells

Per the product page (read 17 Nov 2026):

  • Market and timeframe: 17 forex pairs, M15, MetaTrader 5. For testing, the vendor recommends EURCAD on M15.
  • Logic: “scalping short- and medium-term corrections and market reversals, trading through pending limit orders”. On the signals, however, positions stay open for several days on average.
  • Risk management: “Every trade protected by a Stop Loss”, calculated from market structure; plus “No Martingale, no averaging”.
  • Account: per the vendor any MT5 broker, leverage from 1:30, minimum capital $500. The page gives no recommended risk per trade in percent; lot size is driven by a parameter for how much capital each lot step requires.
  • Price: $599, free demo. Plus: “BONUS FOR EVERY CUSTOMER: Every customer who purchases this bot will receive a free GRABBER BOT: This offer is available for a limited time only. So hurry!” (read 17 Nov 2026). That is scarcity marketing, not a quality feature.
  • Promises: “No hype, No reckless risk. Trading with minimal drawdown” and “Suitable for prop-firm and personal accounts, meeting strict risk management standards”.
  • Maintenance: per the vendor, set files are updated every six months. Version 5.25 dates from 18 Sep 2026.

The two signals

The product page links one signal. A second one bearing the EA's name is in the vendor's signal list:

SignalBrokerstarted
2338672 “One Man Army Double Shot” (linked on the product page)IC Markets20 Oct 2025
2332504 “One Man Army One Shot”Capital Point Trading18 Sep 2025

What they show up to 17 Nov 2026:

  • Account type: real-money accounts per the MQL5 rules, which only admit real-money accounts for signals; both pages show the “Real Account” icon, on the broker's live server. Which set files and how much risk run there is unknown.
  • Duration: both over a year. The One Shot signal started almost a month before the launch, the Double Shot signal a few days after it.
  • Drawdown: on the Double Shot signal, the worst value from drawdown by balance and by equity is significant; on the One Shot signal it is moderate. For an EA with a stop per trade that is not dramatic, but it does not match “minimal drawdown”.
  • Course: on the Double Shot signal most of the growth came from February to July 2026. Since August 2026 the account has been treading water and gave some back in the autumn. On the One Shot signal the account grew more evenly but more slowly; from January to March 2026 MQL5 repeatedly warned there that most of the growth came from very few days. That warning has since disappeared.
  • Deposits and withdrawals: money was paid in and out of both accounts during their lifetime. MQL5's growth curve accounts for this, but it makes the balance harder to read.
  • Leverage and load: both accounts run at 1:500 leverage; at that leverage the deposit load stayed low. With EU leverage (at most 1:30 on major pairs, 1:20 on minors and gold) a large part of capital would be tied up as margin at peak, well over half on the Double Shot signal. Anyone wanting to replicate the position sizes has to cut lots considerably. That contradicts the product page, which says: “no high leverage needed (1:30 is sufficient)” (read 17 Nov 2026).

We do not show the figures in the text; that applies to every EA on AlgoVerdict (methodology). How to read signal metrics is covered in the guide trading metrics.

Critical assessment

1. “No averaging” and “micro-averaging”. The product page rules out additional entries. The description of the signal that the same product page links says: “the advisor uses micro-averaging—no more than 3 trades on a single asset at a time. Each trade is protected by an independent Stop Loss order.” (read 17 Nov 2026). In the comments the vendor explains Double Shot as two positions per pair, “no grid, no averaging, no doubling down” (read 17 Nov 2026). Both can be consistent if each position is protected individually. For the risk it still means: with the Double Shot set, a multiple of the single-trade risk can be in the market per pair. More in the guide position sizing and risk per trade.

2. Many pairs, little diversification. 17 pairs sounds like a broad spread. On the signals, though, AUD, NZD and CAD crosses dominate, and they often move alike. If a trend runs against these currencies, several stops are hit at once. One buyer describes exactly such a losing month in January 2026, when almost every currency rose against the US dollar.

3. Long sideways phases. A system with fixed stops and reversal entries needs patience: there are months in which little happens or several stops come in a row. Satisfied buyers confirm this too. One buyer, by contrast, writes in January 2026 that the EA opens positions without recognisable logic and runs into drawdowns that sometimes last months; another writes tersely on 3 Oct 2026: “Overfitted. RRR” (read 17 Nov 2026). The developer rejected both reviews in his replies. In the first case he pointed, in essence, to a high return within a few months at a low drawdown and called the review subjective. We cannot judge whether overfitting is present; the flat phase since August 2026 on the linked signal, however, is documented.

4. Prop firm marketing without a prop firm account. The EA is advertised as suitable for prop firms, “meeting strict risk management standards”. The drawdown on the linked signal exceeds what typical challenges allow in total, and the vendor shows no account with a daily and overall limit. When a buyer asked about a prop account, he recommended a setting and wrote: “This trading drawdown will not exceed the daily and maximum DD values you specified.” (read 17 Nov 2026). For an EA that exits at stops this cannot be guaranteed; it depends on lot size, pairs and market phase, and there is no public account with such limits. Another buyer writes that he had no luck at prop firms running all pairs at once. Basics: passing a prop firm challenge with an EA.

5. Reviews. 28 reviews averaging 4.67 (as of 17 Nov 2026). Most praise the stop-loss, profit over a longer period and support; one buyer who has used it since launch writes that occasional stops are normal for an EA with a fixed stop and that the balance grows over time. The critical voices are named above. All of these are user reports, not verified data.

How the grade comes about

We grade One Man Army on the same six criteria as every EA (calculation):

  • Risk control: the worst drawdown from balance and equity across both signals is significant. A small deduction because the Double Shot set holds up to three positions per pair and many pairs move alike.
  • Verifiability: two public accounts over more than a year would score higher by formula than we allow for vendor accounts. We go below that because both are run by the vendor, have deposits and withdrawals, and the older one started before the launch.
  • Transparency: logic, stops, set files and fixed-lot backtests are open. A deduction for the contradiction between “no averaging” and “micro-averaging” and because the signals' sets are not stated.
  • Price and value: $599 sits in the $500 to $1,000 band.
  • Usability: neutral mark; we have not tested the installation ourselves.
  • Broker independence: two brokers evidenced, no scalping in the narrow sense.

Who it does (not) suit

Suitable for traders looking for an EA with a fixed stop per trade who can sit through sideways and losing phases lasting months and set the risk per trade low themselves. Anyone checking it tests the demo first in the strategy tester on your own broker's data, then a separate account with the default sets.

Not suitable for anyone counting on “minimal drawdown”, for prop firm accounts with all pairs at full risk, and as the only EA in a portfolio that already holds many CAD or AUD positions. How drawdowns of several EAs add up is described in the guide EA portfolio management.

Verdict

One Man Army is one of the more down-to-earth EAs on the MQL5 market: limit orders, a stop per trade, per the product page no grid and no martingale, limited averaging in the Double Shot set (at most three positions per pair, each with a stop) and two signals running for more than a year. Against that stand a significant drawdown, a flat to falling phase since late summer 2026, additional entries in the linked Double Shot signal despite “no averaging”, and prop firm marketing without proof. We grade One Man Army with the same formula as every EA. We earn nothing from the EA itself; we link the vendor and MQL5 only as sources, never as partner links. Links marked “Ad” on this page (VPS, ATS-listed alternatives) are partner links. Past results are no guarantee of future ones, and trading leveraged products can lead to the loss of the capital invested.

What you need to run it

  • Broker with low spreads on AUDCAD, GBPCAD, NZDCAD, EURAUDRaw or ECN account, no EA restrictionsrequired
  • VPS close to the brokerThe EA has to run around the clockrequired
  • Fix the risk per tradeChoose a lot size that fits the accountset it up yourself

For and against

In favour

  • Every trade with its own stop-loss per the product page, no grid and no martingale described
  • Two public signals on real-money accounts (per the MQL5 rules) at two brokers, both over a year old
  • Low deposit load on both signals, though at 1:500 leverage
  • Set files and installation guide are public; the vendor's backtests use a fixed lot size

Against

  • Significant drawdown (worst value from balance and equity) on the signal linked from the product page
  • Since late summer 2026 a flat to falling phase on the linked signal; buyers report drawdowns lasting months
  • “No averaging” on the product page, but “micro-averaging” with up to three trades per asset in the Double Shot signal's description
  • With EU leverage a large part of capital would be tied up as margin at peak, although the product page calls 1:30 sufficient
  • Prop firm suitability is advertised but not backed by any public account with prop firm limits
  • Deposits and withdrawals on both signals make the growth curve harder to read
  • A portfolio of many CAD and AUD crosses is less diversified than 17 pairs suggest

Buying and running

Our interests: We earn no commission on One Man Army and link neither the vendor nor MQL5. ATS pays us a commission when you buy through the link to the alternatives. We develop our own EA, Dawnbreak. We have no stake in One Man Army. The grade is set beforehand and independently of that.

Terms

Ad
Price
$599
Sold
MQL5 market only
Alternatives at ATS

We do not link to One Man Army itself. The affiliate link changes neither grade nor text.

What we do not know

  • Which set files and how much risk the signals run.They are real-money accounts on live servers. We cannot confirm exactly which pairs, sets and lot sizes run there.
  • Whether the flat phase since late summer 2026 ends.The linked signal has barely grown since August 2026 and gave some back in the autumn. Only the further course will show whether this is a normal sideways phase or the end of a favourable market.
  • How the EA fares under prop firm limits.The vendor advertises prop firm suitability; there is no public account with a daily and overall limit.

Frequently asked questions

What is One Man Army?

An Expert Advisor for MetaTrader 5 by Ihor Otkydach, on the MQL5 market since 14 Oct 2025, priced at $599 on 17 Nov 2026. It trades 17 forex pairs on M15 and, per the product page, places limit orders in zones where it expects a reversal. Every trade has its own stop-loss.

Does One Man Army use grid or martingale?

Per the product page, no: “No Martingale, no averaging”. The “Double Shot” signal linked from the product page, however, describes “micro-averaging” with at most three trades per asset, each with its own stop. That is limited averaging (at most three positions per pair, each with a stop), not an unlimited grid, but it raises the volume per pair. Anyone using the Double Shot set should factor that into the risk.

Are the One Man Army signals real-money accounts?

Yes, the MQL5 signal rules only admit real-money accounts, and both pages label the account as Real Account on the broker's live server (read 17 Nov 2026). Which set files and how much risk run there is unknown. The vendor runs both accounts himself.

Is One Man Army suitable for prop firms?

The vendor advertises it as such. There is no public account with prop firm limits, and the drawdown on the linked signal exceeds what typical challenges allow in total. One buyer writes that he had no luck at prop firms running all pairs at once. Anyone trying should set the risk well below that of the signals.

What do buyers say about One Man Army?

Most of the 28 reviews (average 4.67, as of 17 Nov 2026) praise the stop-loss, long-term profit and support. Two critical reviews speak of overfitting and of drawdowns lasting months. The developer rejected both. These are individual buyers' reports, not verified data.

Is there a verified live track for One Man Army?

Yes, 2 public signals on real-money accounts (per MQL5 rules), selected by the vendor. Which settings run there is not disclosed. Because the vendor chooses what to show, such accounts earn at most 8.0 out of 10 for evidence. We deliberately do not show returns or drawdowns.

Changes to this review

  1. First published. Product page, reviews, comments, two MQL5 signals and the MQL5 signal rules read on 17 Nov 2026.
  2. Second review by an AI agent (different model, blind): 5 of 6 criteria agree. Differences:
  3. Transparenz: Zweitprüfung 5,6, unsere Bewertung 7,4. Grundlogik, Stop-Loss-Ansatz, Märkte und Pflegehinweise sind beschrieben, aber die Signal-Sets fehlen und die Aussagen zu Nachkäufen beziehungsweise Micro-Averaging sind widersprüchlich.

More forex EAs we reviewed

Compare MQL5 EAs