Overview
Iron Stops by Fajar Dicky Firmansyah is a gold EA for MetaTrader 5, on the MQL5 Market since 14 August 2026. It has many buyers and a lively comment section in which praise and serious doubts sit side by side. What can actually be checked is thin: a single young signal on a very small account, a predecessor signal that is no longer available and a logic described in one sentence. Our grade is provisional. The EA is not available at AlgoTradingSpace.
What the vendor sells
According to the product page (read 17 Nov 2026):
- Market and timeframe: XAUUSD on M30 only, one chart is enough.
- Logic: “Volume Acceleration”, i.e. detecting sudden volume shifts that often precede a breakout. Per the vendor, positions close within 36 hours.
- Risk: automatic lot sizing from balance and stop-loss distance or fixed lots, plus a guard that stops trading beyond a set floating loss. Version 1.18 of 28 Aug 2026 added a trailing stop and new risk options.
- Marketing claim: “No gimmicks. No empty claims.” Iron Stops stays within set limits, whether in a prop challenge or with client funds.
- Documentation: an ini file for correct backtests and configuration files are only available on request or in a Telegram channel for buyers.
A stop-loss on every position is not explicitly promised on the page. Lot sizing from the stop distance does presuppose a stop, though, and buyers report in the comments that stops were set at the broker. The page describes no grid or averaging.
Price and bonus
On 17 Nov 2026 the buy button shows $349. The description text says at the same time (read 17 Nov 2026): “This EA currently costs 580. Once 30 licenses are purchased, the price will increase to 629.” On 26 Aug 2026 the developer wrote in the comments: “the price is now 580 and it will be 699 soon and over 1k very soon” (read 17 Nov 2026). One buyer reports in his review that he paid $130. Which price applied when can no longer be traced; what counts is the price on the buy button. Announcements of rising prices are marketing and should not put buyers under time pressure.
The vendor also advertises “FREE BONUS: Buy one, Get 2!” (read 17 Nov 2026): after purchase, further EAs are available on request. The product page does not describe what the extra EAs do; one buyer writes that the bonus EA did not work in his backtests. The bonus should play no part in the buying decision.
The signal
On the product page the vendor links one signal, “New Iron Stop signal” (2395437), on the Alpari-MT5 server with 1:500 leverage, started on 13 October 2026. Per its description it runs with default settings. Hovering over the same link, the tooltip still shows the address of an older signal (2386516). That signal is no longer available (probably deleted, according to MQL5).
What the current signal shows as of 17 November 2026, without figures, as in all our reviews:
- Account type: real-money account per MQL5 rules, which allow only real-money accounts for signals; MQL5 shows the “Real Account” icon, and the server is a live server. Which settings run there beyond “default settings” is open.
- Account size: the account started with a very small amount, and a large part of it has already been withdrawn.
- Drawdown: the worst value from balance and equity, here the relative drawdown by balance, is very deep: at times the account stood more than half below its peak. That is the lowest tier of the table in the calculation.
- Margin usage: maximum margin usage was moderate; this suggests the drawdown came less from many simultaneous positions than from the size of single losses relative to the small account.
- Growth: MQL5 notes that most of the growth came on a single day and warns that a large drawdown may occur again. The curve therefore overstates everyday trading.
- Holding time: several hours on average, so no scalping.
How to read signal metrics correctly is covered in the guide trading metrics.
What buyers report
On the MQL5 Market, Iron Stops stands at 4.01 out of 5 from 83 reviews, plus 354 comments (as of 17 Nov 2026). Buyer reviews do not count toward our grade. Many buyers report profits and praise fast replies from the developer. Others report losses and say that live trading and backtest do not match for them.
The critical points, without judgement on our part:
- Doubts about the backtests. In August 2026 a buyer published his own technical analysis in the comments. In it he doubts that the vendor's backtests say anything about future results. Other commenters observe entries at recurring times. The developer disagreed on 26 Aug 2026: “i never did put anything like trades or dates in my code” (read 17 Nov 2026). Backtest and live trading matched, he said. We can check neither the analysis nor the reply. Vendor backtests do not count toward our grade.
- Lot sizing. One buyer reports that with automatic lot sizing a backtest on another symbol produced a trade with an unusually large lot size, and recommends fixed lots. The developer explains that the lot size depends on balance and stop distance. Anyone testing the EA should check the lot sizes in the journal.
- Differences between brokers. Several buyers report that the same trade was opened at different brokers with a different stop-loss and ended once in profit, once in loss. The developer attributes this to market conditions on that day.
Critical assessment
1. One signal is not a track record. A few weeks on a very small account do not show how Iron Stops handles a longer difficult gold phase. That the older signal is no longer available does not help.
2. The drawdown does not match the promise. The vendor advertises consistency and limits suited to prop challenges. On the only signal, the drawdown by balance has been very deep so far. Anyone planning a prop challenge should hold the firm's daily and overall loss limits against it; background in the guide gold EA for prop firms.
3. Leverage and risk setting. The signal trades with 1:500 leverage. EU retail clients get at most 1:20 on gold and 1:30 on forex majors. The product page names no recommended risk per trade; according to buyer reports, the risk input as a percentage of balance also accepts very high values. A stop limits the single loss only as far as the lot size allows. Anyone testing should start with small fixed lots.
4. The logic remains a black box. One sentence on the strategy, settings only on request and an open dispute about the backtests: what Iron Stops does can only be inferred from the trading history, and that is short. Why backtests on gold often look much better than live trading is shown in gold EA: backtest vs. live.
How the provisional grade comes about
We grade Iron Stops on the same six criteria as every EA (calculation):
- Risk control: the worst drawdown from balance and equity on the signal counts (here relative by balance). It sits in the lowest tier. A small deduction for the very high leverage, the open risk input and the reported lot-size outlier.
- Verifiability: one public account would give more under the formula. We lower it clearly: very small account with a withdrawal, a few weeks, a predecessor signal that is no longer available, an account chosen by the vendor.
- Transparency: the public signal counts in its favour. Deductions for the brief description of the logic, settings only on request, the signal that is no longer available, the contradictory pricing and the unresolved doubts about the backtests.
- Price and value: $349 is in the middle band.
- Usability: neutral mark, we have not tested the installation ourselves.
- Broker independence: evidenced at one broker, a small deduction for the reported differences between brokers.
As with every EA, an AI from a different model family also grades blind; where it deviates strongly, the mean counts until a human has re-checked. For Iron Stops this applies to transparency and broker independence: there the mean of our mark and the stricter second review counts. We will review the grade once the signal has run for several months.
Who it is (not) suitable for
If you want to check it: first the demo in the strategy tester with your own broker's data and across several periods, then a separate small account with small fixed lots and low leverage, and only money you can afford to lose. Check the lot size of every trade in the journal.
Not suitable for anyone who needs an evidenced track record, for prop firm accounts while the signal shows such a deep drawdown, and as a second gold EA next to another gold system such as The Gold Reaper: that is the same bet twice (see EA portfolio management). How other gold EAs compare is shown in best gold EA 2026.
Verdict
Iron Stops is a gold EA with lot sizing from the stop distance per the vendor, without a described grid, at a shop price of $349. Against that stand a single young signal on a very small account with a very deep drawdown, a predecessor signal that is no longer available, contradictory pricing and unresolved doubts about the backtests. Our grade is therefore provisional and low. We grade Iron Stops with the same formula as every EA. We earn nothing from the EA itself; we link the vendor and MQL5 only as sources, never as partner links. Links marked “Ad” on this page (VPS, ATS-listed alternatives) are partner links. Past results are no guarantee of future ones, and trading leveraged products can lead to the loss of the capital invested.
