Skip to content
AlgoVerdict
Menu
Hedgehog MT5 product shot

EA review ·

Hedgehog MT5

provisional

Hedgehog MT5

3 signals on real-money accounts (per MQL5 rules), selected by the vendor

The vendor lists 3 public signals. We checked that they exist and can be viewed. The seller still chooses what to show, so such evidence earns at most 8.0 for verifiability.

Checked
Signal exists and is public · real money per the MQL5 signal rules, broker’s live server · trading behaviour matches the described design
Not shown
Return, drawdown, running time. Past figures tempt buyers more than they inform them.
Counts towards
Verifiability (25% of the grade): 5.6 out of 10
Strength of evidence
2 of 3: selected by the seller
ScalpingXAUUSDMT5

Reviewed by Pitt Petruschke, operator. No stake in Hedgehog MT5; receives commission from ATS and develops his own EA, Dawnbreak. Disclosure

Verdict

Provisional grade: a stop-loss per the vendor and three public signals, but secret logic, very high leverage and a track of a few weeks.

Hedgehog MT5 by Thomas Christoph Lipka is a gold EA (XAUUSD, H1) for MT5, on the MQL5 market since 7 Nov 2026 for $299. The vendor explicitly keeps the trading logic secret, and the three public signals only started in mid-October 2026, with very high leverage. A strong start is not yet evidence. Provisional grade.

Suits you if …

  • Yes: your broker offers raw spreads and fast execution
  • Yes: the EA runs on a VPS close to the broker server
  • Caution: you watch spread spikes at rollover and news
  • Caution: you set setfile and risk yourself, without ATS calibration

Evidence behind this verdict

  • MQL5 market: Hedgehog MT5 (price, version, release, description, reviews and vendor replies)read 17 November 2026
  • MQL5 signal 2395236: Hedgehog MT5 Ultima (Ultima Markets)read 17 November 2026
  • MQL5 signal 2395384: Hedgehog MT5 Vantageread 17 November 2026

How the strategy trades

Schematic · no market dataSchematic of the Scalper strategy type: it explains the process, not the outcome. No prices, no real market data, no performance of Hedgehog MT5.

Example · closed

How it works

  1. While price is above the EMA 20, the uptrend holds.
  2. After a small pullback the EA buys 0.10 lots with a tight target (+6 pips) and a stop twice as wide (−12 pips).
  3. Each trade earns little; the many small gains add up. Because the stop is larger than the target, the hit rate has to stay high – and spread and slippage take their biggest bite here.

What we check

What we check on real scalpers: whether live results hold up to the backtest once real spreads, commissions and slippage kick in – and with which broker.

Schematic with demonstration values: a simulated price path without prices, results in pips weighted to 0.10 lots, deliberately favourable. Not this EA’s market or settings, not a backtest and not investment advice.

Design & risk

Hedgehog MT5 by Thomas Christoph Lipka is a Scalping EA on XAUUSD (MT5), sold on the MQL5 market. The EA holds positions briefly and lives on small moves, so spread, commission and execution speed matter more than for other designs. You buy the vendor default; risk frame and setfile are up to you.

Newsletter · Sundays

New EA reviews, by email on Sundays

Before you buy your next EA: once a week, the digest brings the new and updated reviews.

  • New EA reviews with grade and verdict
  • What changed in existing verdicts
  • A note when something material changes on a signal we track

By subscribing you agree to receive the digest by email. You confirm via a link (double opt-in) and can unsubscribe anytime via the link in every email. Details in the privacy policy.

The full review

Overview

Hedgehog MT5 is the newest gold EA from Thomas Christoph Lipka, who already sells Ghost Scalper and other gold EAs on the MQL5 market. The first weeks look very good on the signals, and the first buyers are enthusiastic. That is exactly why a sober look pays off: the trading logic is secret, the track is a few weeks old, and the signal accounts trade with very high leverage. Our grade is provisional.

What the vendor sells

Per the product page (read 17 Nov 2026):

  • Market and timeframe: XAUUSD only, H1, MetaTrader 5.
  • Price: $299, plus a free demo for the strategy tester.
  • Released on 7 Nov 2026, current version 1.0.
  • Risk control: automatic stop-loss and take-profit, trailing stop, slippage monitoring, a filter for high-impact economic news, fixed or automatic lot size.
  • Account: per the vendor about $300 at a fixed lot size of 0.01, $1,000 or more recommended with automatic risk calculation. ECN, raw-spread or pro accounts and a VPS are recommended. The vendor adds that these amounts guarantee neither sufficient margin nor protection against losses.

What the page does not say: how the EA finds entries. It speaks of a "proprietary analytical framework" and states: "Its underlying trading methodology and calculations remain proprietary." It does not describe a grid or martingale, but does not explicitly rule them out either.

We list Hedgehog as a scalper. That describes the observed behaviour, not the logic: in all three signals positions are open for less than a minute on average. The product page sets Hedgehog apart from systems that hold many pending orders for days; that it trades breakouts with pending orders itself is likely, but only an assumption.

The three signals

The vendor links three public MQL5 signals, one per broker:

SignalBrokerstarted
2395236 (Ultima signal)Ultima Markets12 Oct 2026
2395384 (Vantage signal)Vantage13 Oct 2026
2395385 (VT signal)VT Markets13 Oct 2026

As of 17 Nov 2026, all three have therefore run for only about five weeks. They started just under four weeks before the product launch. What they show up to 17 Nov 2026:

  • Account type: real-money accounts per the MQL5 rules, which only allow real-money accounts for signals, on each broker's live server. Which settings and how much risk run there is unknown.
  • Very high growth within a few weeks on all three accounts. MQL5 itself shows warnings on each of the three pages: too much growth in the last month indicates high risk, the account is new and the results may be random, and copying carries a risk of negative slippage.
  • Short holding time: on average, positions close in under a minute.
  • Decline: with holding times this short, the open loss is practically not measurable on MQL5. What counts is the decline by balance. Over these few weeks it was moderate; that is no evidence for difficult phases.

We do not show the figures themselves; that applies to every EA on AlgoVerdict (methodology). With Hedgehog a return after a few weeks would be especially misleading: it mainly says that things went well so far, not how the EA survives a bad month. How to read signal metrics properly is explained in the guide on trading metrics.

Critical assessment

1. The logic is not disclosed. For an EA with a stop-loss that is no reason to rule it out, but it shifts the whole assessment onto the trade history. And that is short. What a seller does not disclose may only show in a market phase the track has not seen yet.

2. A few weeks are not a track record. Five weeks of gold are a single market phase. A system can win almost every trade in such a period and give a large part of it back in the next. Our guide Gold EA: backtest vs. live describes this with several examples.

3. Very high returns in a short time mean high risk. Earning a lot within a few weeks means a large stake per trade, a favourable phase, or both. MQL5 flags exactly this as a risk on all three signals. Buyers should not plan with this curve, but with clearly worse months.

4. Leverage and position size. The signals trade with very high leverage and positions that are very large relative to the account. A stop only protects when execution is clean: if the gold price gaps through the stop, for example on news, a single trade can cost a large part of the account. Anyone copying or replicating it should plan for lower leverage and smaller lots.

5. Execution matters. Positions that are open for less than a minute on average react sensitively to spread, latency and slippage. That is why the vendor himself recommends raw-spread accounts and a VPS. On a standard account, or when copying a signal, results can be worse. More in gold scalping EAs and VPS for EAs.

6. The vendor's tone. On 11 Nov 2026 the vendor replied under a review with a flawless win record for the first trades and the claim that the purchase price had already been earned back several times over (read 17 Nov 2026). That is not a verified figure but advertising, and it points to exactly what says the least after four days of sales. The 13 reviews with an average of 4.89 (as of 17 Nov 2026) all date from the first ten days. One buyer writes himself that a reliable statement needs a longer track.

Relation to Ghost Scalper and other gold EAs

Hedgehog is the next gold EA from the same developer as Ghost Scalper. One buyer recommends running both together. It is not documented that they move independently: both trade only gold. Anyone already running a gold EA, such as The Gold Reaper, stacks the same bet with Hedgehog. The guide on EA portfolio management shows what that does to the combined drawdown.

How the provisional grade comes about

We grade Hedgehog on the same six criteria as every EA (calculation) and deliberately go lower wherever the data formula would be too generous:

  • Risk control: the decline on the signals so far lies in a range the formula rates well. We deduct because a few weeks do not replace the starting value from the design: the logic is secret, the signals trade with very high leverage and large positions, and a price gap through the stop has not happened in them yet.
  • Verifiability: three signals would earn more under the formula. We lower it clearly, because the track is a few weeks old, began before the launch, the accounts are chosen by the vendor and the settings on them are unknown.
  • Transparency: public signals count in its favour, an explicitly secret trading logic clearly against it.
  • Price and value: $299 sits in the middle band.
  • Usability: a neutral mark; we have not tested the installation ourselves.
  • Broker independence: three brokers are documented. Deductions because the very short holding time makes the EA depend on good execution and the vendor runs all three accounts with very high leverage.

We will re-check the grade once the signals have run for several months or a larger decline occurs.

Who it does (not) suit

If you want to test it: first the demo version in the strategy tester with your own broker's data, then a separate small account with raw spreads and a VPS, lower leverage and small lots, the default settings instead of raised risk, and only money you can afford to lose. Follow the signals over several months before adding capital.

Not suitable for anyone who needs a proven track record, for buyers who extrapolate the curve so far, as a second gold EA next to another gold system, and for prop firm accounts until a longer history shows how deep the declines can go. Basics: gold EAs at prop firms.

Verdict

Hedgehog MT5 has a strong start, a stop-loss per the vendor and three public signals on real-money accounts (per MQL5 rules) at three brokers. Against that stand a secret trading logic, very high leverage and a track of about five weeks. Very high profits in such a short time are a warning sign, not proof of quality. Our grade is therefore provisional. We grade Hedgehog with the same formula as every EA. We earn nothing from the EA itself and link neither the vendor nor MQL5. The links on this page marked "Ad" (VPS, ATS-listed alternatives) are partner links. Past results are no guarantee of future ones, and trading leveraged products can lead to the loss of the capital invested.

What you need to run it

  • Broker with low spreads on XAUUSDRaw account with commission and fast executionrequired
  • VPS close to the brokerThe EA has to run around the clockrequired
  • Fix the risk per tradeChoose a lot size that fits the accountset it up yourself

For and against

In favour

  • Stop-loss, take-profit and trailing stop per the product page, no grid or martingale described
  • Three public signals on real-money accounts (per MQL5 rules) at three different brokers that anyone can inspect
  • Free demo version for your own backtests with your broker's data

Against

  • The trading logic is explicitly secret: what the EA does can only be inferred from its trade history
  • Very short track: the signals only started in mid-October 2026, not a single difficult market phase is on record
  • Very high growth within a few weeks means high risk; MQL5 itself warns about it on all three signals (read 17 Nov 2026)
  • Very high leverage and large positions relative to the account: a price gap through the stop can cost a large part of the account
  • Which settings and how much risk run on the signal accounts is unknown
  • Positions close on average in under a minute: spread, latency and slippage matter
  • A promotional reply from the vendor under the reviews that puts profits front and centre

Buying and running

Our interests: We earn no commission on Hedgehog MT5 and link neither the vendor nor MQL5. ATS pays us a commission when you buy through the link to the alternatives. We develop our own EA, Dawnbreak. We have no stake in Hedgehog MT5. The grade is set beforehand and independently of that.

Terms

Ad
Price
$299
Sold
MQL5 market only
Alternatives at ATS

We do not link to Hedgehog MT5 itself. The affiliate link changes neither grade nor text.

What we do not know

  • How the strategy finds entries.The vendor keeps methodology and calculations secret. That it trades breakouts via pending orders is only an assumption.
  • Which settings the signals run.They are real-money accounts on live servers. Which settings and how much risk run on them, we cannot confirm.
  • How the EA copes with a difficult gold phase.The track covers a few weeks. A sharp gold sell-off, a long sideways phase or a news shock is not on record.

Frequently asked questions

What is Hedgehog MT5?

An Expert Advisor for MetaTrader 5 that trades only gold (XAUUSD) on the H1 timeframe. It comes from Thomas Christoph Lipka and has been sold on the MQL5 market since 7 Nov 2026 for $299 (as of 17 Nov 2026). Per the product page it uses a stop-loss, take-profit, trailing stop and news filter. How it finds entries, the vendor does not disclose.

What strategy does Hedgehog MT5 use?

That is not known. The product page explicitly calls the methodology and calculations “proprietary” (read 17 Nov 2026). Only the market, the timeframe, the stop-loss management and a very short holding time in the signals are documented. We list it as a scalper because that is how it behaves in the signals, not because the logic is known. That it trades breakouts with pending orders is an assumption.

Are the Hedgehog MT5 signals real-money accounts?

Yes. The MQL5 signal rules only allow real-money accounts; demo, contest and cent accounts are not permitted. All three signals run on the brokers' live servers (read 17 Nov 2026). What remains unknown is which settings and how much risk run there. The vendor chooses the accounts himself.

Why is the grade provisional?

Because the signals only started on 12 and 13 Oct 2026, so about five weeks ago (as of 17 Nov 2026). In such a short time an EA with secret logic may simply have been lucky. We will re-check the grade once the signals have run for several months or a larger decline occurs.

Does Hedgehog MT5 go well with Ghost Scalper from the same vendor?

Not for diversification. Both trade only gold and both come from the same developer. Running both mainly raises the gold risk in a portfolio. One buyer praises the combination in a review; a low correlation is not documented.

Is there a verified live track for Hedgehog MT5?

Yes, 3 public signals on real-money accounts (per MQL5 rules), selected by the vendor. Which settings run there is not disclosed. Because the vendor chooses what to show, such accounts earn at most 8.0 out of 10 for evidence. We deliberately do not show returns or drawdowns.

Changes to this review

  1. First published with a provisional grade. Product page, three MQL5 signals and the MQL5 signal rules read on 17 Nov 2026.

More commodity EAs we reviewed

Compare gold EAs

Compare MQL5 EAs