Gold EAs need a different broker comparison
A broker that is cheap on EUR/USD is not automatically cheap on gold. Gold has wider spreads, faster price jumps and a 100-ounce lot on which every cent of price difference costs 1 USD. For a gold EA, three things therefore matter that the usual broker rankings leave out: the gold spread, the gold commission and how cleanly a triggered stop gets filled.
This page only puts figures side by side that we can document: average spreads and commissions published by the brokers themselves (as of 1 Oct 2026) and our analysis of real MT5 accounts from the public tracker of Algo Trading Space Ad (as of 2 Nov 2026). For brokers that publish no gold average we give no spread; we do not use estimates or "from" values. Our broker scores do not change because of this page.
Disclosure: RoboForex, IC Markets, FP Trading Ad and BlackBull Ad are partners of ours, Tickmill and Pepperstone are not. If you sign up through a partner link, we receive a commission.
Gold cost per lot as stated by the broker
Average XAUUSD spread per the broker's website (raw/ECN account), converted to a standard lot of 100 ounces, plus commission for one round turn. As of 1 Oct 2026.
| Broker | Account | Avg. XAUUSD spread | Spread per lot | Commission per lot (round turn) | Total per lot | Period stated by broker |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RoboForex | Prime | 0.05 USD | 5 USD | by volume, not stated per lot | from 5 USD + commission | not stated |
| FP Trading | Raw ECN | 0.09 USD | 9 USD | 6 USD | 15 USD | not stated |
| Tickmill | Raw | 0.09 USD (typical) | 9 USD | 6 USD | 15 USD | not stated |
| Pepperstone | Razor | 0.12 USD | 12 USD | 7 USD | 19 USD | 1–31 Aug 2026 |
| IC Markets | Raw Spread | no gold average published | – | 7 USD | – | – |
| BlackBull | ECN Prime | only "from" values published | – | 6 USD | – | – |
Notes on the sources:
- RoboForex states the Prime account's gold spread in pips of 0.01 (average 5, i.e. 0.05 USD). Commission is only given as a volume figure: 10 USD per 1M — round turn ≈ 2 USD per lot (Prime); lot = 100,000 USD notional. We have not converted that into USD per lot for gold, because the notional value of a gold lot depends on the gold price.
- FP Trading shows no unit for the gold value on its spreads page; we read 0.09 as USD. Commission per the account page: 3.00 USD / 2.75 EUR / 2.25 GBP per lot per side (Raw, 6 USD round turn).
- Tickmill gives a "typical" spread, not explicitly an average, and 3 USD per lot per side for FX and precious metals on the Raw account (EU site).
- Pepperstone gives the gold average for August 2026; the Razor gold commission on MT4/MT5 is listed on its pricing page as "from 3.50 USD per lot, per side".
- IC Markets lists gold on its EU site only as a futures CFD with no XAUUSD average, and BlackBull only publishes "from" values. That is why both are missing from the total column, not because they are expensive.
Newsletter · Sundays
Broker reviews and changes by email
Once a week: new and updated broker and EA reviews, each summed up briefly with a link.
- New and updated broker reviews with grade
- New guides, each summed up in one sentence
- Only when there is news, one-click unsubscribe
Execution: what a gold stop really costs
The spread is only half the bill. When a stop-loss on gold triggers, the broker fills at the next available price, and in fast markets that can be far from the stop. For three brokers we analysed the fills of real MT5 accounts from the public tracker of Algo Trading Space:
Live test compared · every account in the ATS tracker
| Metric | IC Markets | RoboForex | BlackBull |
|---|---|---|---|
| Real-money accounts | 64 | 62 | 126 |
| Closed trades | 39,349 | 26,244 | 64,902 |
| MT5 / MT4 | 49 / 15 | 53 / 9 | 97 / 29 |
| with / without commission | 56 / 7 | 11 / 51 | 95 / 25 |
| Scalper accounts | 12 | 10 | 22 |
| Gold stop-loss, median (USD per lot) | 6.0 | 6.0 | 15.0 |
| Gold stop-loss, mean (USD per lot) | 16.4 | 14.8 | 26.8 |
| Gold take-profit with price improvement | 64.8 % | 86.5 % | 50.2 % |
| Gold net per exit (USD per lot) | 5.2 | 0.8 | 20.9 |
| FX stop-loss, median (pips) | 0.10 | 0.10 | 0.10 |
| FX net per exit (pips) | -0.02 | -0.09 | -0.13 |
What the figures show:
- IC Markets and RoboForex are level on triggered gold stops: a median of 6.00 USD per lot at IC Markets and 6.00 USD per lot at RoboForex.
- BlackBull is noticeably more expensive on gold stops: a median of 15.00 USD per lot and a mean of 26.80 USD per lot.
- Take-profits are filled better than the level in 86.5 % of cases at RoboForex and 64.8 % at IC Markets. A broker that passes on price improvement is more likely to route the market through cleanly.
The sample is gold-heavy and the tracker, not chance, decides which accounts are in it. We have no such measurement for FP Trading, Tickmill or Pepperstone. The method and all its limits are in our reviews of IC Markets, RoboForex and BlackBull. What slippage is and why it almost always runs against you on stops is explained in what is slippage?.
Server, regulation and leverage
A gold EA with tight stops needs a VPS close to the trading server. If you size gold positions by leverage, you need to know which entity holds your account.
| Broker | Trading server | Regulation | Max. leverage |
|---|---|---|---|
| RoboForex | Amsterdam (ECN server) (VPS measurement) | FSC Belize (licence 9759600) | 1:2000 (Pro/ProCent) · 1:500 (ECN) · 1:300 (Prime) |
| IC Markets | Equinix NY4 (MT4/MT5) · Equinix LD5 (cTrader) | ASIC (Australia, AFSL 335692), CySEC (EU, 362/18), FSA (Seychelles, SD018) | up to 1:5000 dynamic (Global/FSA, MT) · 1:1000 (cTrader) · EU/CySEC & ASIC: 1:30 |
| FP Trading | NY4 and London LD4 (by server) (VPS measurement) | FSC Mauritius (GB26205878), FSCA South Africa (52858), FSRA St. Lucia (registered, 2026-00106), FSA St. Vincent (registered only, 126 LLC 2019 – no forex supervision), CMA UAE (20200000467, promotion) | up to 1:500 |
| BlackBull | Equinix London (per BlackBull) · also NY4 / TY3 | NZ FSP register (Black Bull Group Ltd, FSP403326), FSA (Seychelles, BBG Ltd, SD045) | 1:500 |
| Tickmill | London (Equinix LD4) (VPS measurement) | FCA (UK, 717270), CySEC (Cyprus/EU, 278/15), FSA (Seychelles, SD008), FSCA (South Africa, FSP 49464), DFSA (Dubai, F007663, representative office); EU entity registered with BaFin (146511) | up to 1:1000 dynamic (FSA entity, Tickmill Trader) · 1:30 retail / 1:500 pro (EU) |
| Pepperstone | Equinix NY4 (VPS measurement) | ASIC (Australia, AFSL 414530), FCA (UK, 684312), CySEC (Cyprus/EU, 388/20), DFSA (Dubai, F004356), BaFin (Germany, 151148), CMA (Kenya, licence 128), SCB (Bahamas, SIA-F217) | 1:30 retail (ASIC/FCA/CySEC/BaFin) · 1:200 retail (SCB) · 1:500 pro clients only |
Locations without a note in brackets come from the broker itself; a note such as "VPS measurement" means the location was derived from VPS providers' latency measurements. Which VPS location you need for which broker is shown in broker server locations.
What is missing here: we do not hold swap rates or minimum lot sizes for XAUUSD as verified data, so we quote none. Swaps are listed in the contract specification inside the terminal; the swap calculator works out what they cost per trade, month and year. How much margin a gold position ties up at your leverage is shown by the margin calculator.
Which broker fits which gold EA
- Gold scalpers and breakout EAs with tight stops: cost per round turn and stop execution matter equally. RoboForex Prime has the lowest documented spread and gold stops at IC level; the trade-off is the FSC Belize licence. IC Markets is the alternative with the same measured stop quality, servers in Equinix NY4 and a CySEC entity for EU clients; check the gold spread yourself in the terminal there. Put the VPS in the same data centre.
- Gold swing and trend EAs with few trades: the spread matters less, swaps and regulation more. Tickmill (FCA, CySEC) and Pepperstone (FCA, CySEC and BaFin among others) deliver documented gold costs of 15 and 19 USD per lot under tier-1 supervision; neither is a partner of ours. Work out the swaps for your holding period before you start.
- Gold grid and martingale EAs: many small positions multiply spread and commission, and deep floating losses make leverage a question of survival. A raw account with a low gold spread is a must, and so is a hard equity limit. Why the balance drawdown of such EAs is misleading is covered in grid and martingale EAs: the risks.
- BlackBull is fully suitable for forex EAs; for gold EAs with tight stops, execution costs measurably more according to our data.
Which gold EAs we recommend at all and the setup they run on is in best gold EA 2026. The head-to-head of the two best-known gold EAs is in Gold X9 vs The Gold Reaper, and general spread costs on EUR/USD in lowest-spread brokers.
Where to go next depends on your EA’s design: for scalpers, gold scalping EAs weighs the cost per trade against the price target; for grid and martingale EAs, gold EA risk shows what a basket costs per dollar of gold move. Why spread and stop fills push a gold EA away from its backtest live is explained in gold EA backtest vs. live, and what changes on a prop firm account in gold EAs at prop firms.
All six brokers at a glance
The table below shows our overall scores and the key facts of the six brokers from the individual reviews. The selection follows from the brokers we have gold data for, not from their scores.