Short answer
An MQL5 signal is one of the most meaningful pieces of public evidence an EA vendor can provide: a real account whose entire trading history MQL5 requests from the account. But it is an account the vendor picked, with the vendor’s settings, at the vendor’s broker. This guide shows in eight steps what to check on a signal page and in which order. The examples come from our EA reviews and are deliberately qualitative: we do not show returns or drawdown figures.
The rules quoted are the MQL5 signal rules, read on 19 November 2026. MQL5 may change them; check the current version.
1. Real account: what the rules guarantee and what they do not
Under the rules, signals can only be created on a real account (section III.12). Signals on demo, contest and cent accounts are not allowed and are deleted automatically (III.13). Public signals show deposits and withdrawals as well as fixed and floating profit or loss in real time (III.6).
That rules out a demo account, not selection: a vendor can run several accounts and list only the best as a signal. Nor does it say which settings run on the account. In many of our reviews it is unclear whether the signal trades the default settings a buyer receives.
Check: the “Real Account” icon, the broker’s live server, and whether the product page states which set file the signal runs.
2. Start date against account history
When a signal is set up, the rules say the entire trading history of the account is requested (III.5). The statistics therefore do not start on the day the account becomes a signal but with its first trade. Growth from before that point could not be followed live by anyone.
Check: the date since which the account is listed as a signal against the start of the monthly history. For Quantum Valhalla, all of the reported growth came from before the signal start, for BTC Anchor a large part (both read 17 Nov 2026). Also compare with the EA’s sales launch: a signal that starts days after sales began, as with Pac Man BTC, was no evidence yet when the first customers bought.
3. The warnings from MQL5
MQL5 puts its own notes on some signal pages. In our reviews we read, among others: too much growth in the last month and a high average monthly return point to high risk; the account is new and the results may be random; very frequent trades can make copying worse (signal of Pac Man BTC, read 17 Nov 2026).
These notes come from the platform, not the vendor, and they can change. On the gold signal of Institutional SMC Robot, the growth warning was set and removed several times according to our repeated checks of the signal page.
Check: every warning on the page, and whether one has appeared in the history before.
4. Drawdown by balance and by equity
The signal page lists several declines. Drawdown by balance measures the account balance from closed trades. Drawdown by equity includes floating losses. An EA that keeps losers open or adds to a basket looks calm by balance as long as it does not close; by equity you see how deep the account stood in between.
That is why our grading takes the worst value of maximum and relative drawdown by balance and relative drawdown by equity. Which of them is worst depends on the EA: for BTC Anchor, a grid without a stop-loss per position, it was the relative drawdown by equity; for Pac Man BTC the one by balance (both read 17 Nov 2026). How this enters the grade is shown on the calculation page; the metrics themselves are explained in trading metrics: drawdown and profit factor.
Check: both values side by side. If drawdown by equity is far above drawdown by balance, the EA holds floating losses. Conversely, a small gap proves nothing: on the grid BTC Anchor, both values were close together after a few weeks because the basket had always come back until then.
5. Deposit load
Deposit load shows how much of the account was tied up as margin. A high maximum load means the EA at times traded large positions relative to the account, even if the drawdown stayed small. In our reviews it was high at times for SixtyNine EA, for example, and low for BTC Anchor (as of 17 Nov 2026).
Check: the maximum deposit load, not just the average, and whether it fits the leverage you have yourself.
6. Leverage: 1:500 on the signal, 1:30 for you
Under the rules, signals on accounts with leverage above 1:500 cannot be subscribed to (III.3, IV.2). In our reviews, many signals run right at that limit. Retail clients in the EU get at most 1:30 on major pairs, 1:20 on gold and 1:2 on cryptocurrencies for CFDs, under the 2018 ESMA rules that the national regulators have continued (in Germany, BaFin). You can copy such a signal, but not at the same size: if your leverage is lower, the MQL5 copier scales the positions down in proportion to the leverage, according to the MetaTrader 5 help (read 19 Nov 2026). At 1:30 against 1:500, a small fraction remains, and very small positions are rounded to the minimum lot size. The signals of the Bitcoin EAs Pac Man BTC and BTC Anchor run at 1:500.
Check: the leverage in the header of the signal page, and use the margin calculator to work out how much capital you would need at your leverage to hold the positions at full size. If that is far more than your account, you only copy the signal scaled down.
7. Subscribers
The number of subscribers shows interest, not quality. In our experience, many join after a strong run, often too late. A signal with no subscribers at all is not worse, but more fleeting: under the rules, the provider can then have it removed immediately on request (III.14). The signals of Gold Snap had no subscribers, and copying each cost 999 USD a month (as of 17 Nov 2026); there the signals serve as evidence, not as a copy offer.
Check: subscribers and how they develop, but draw no conclusion about the strategy from them.
8. Copying cost
Under the rules, a signal subscription is charged in advance for the chosen period (V.4), a cancelled subscription is not refunded (V.7), and the provider receives the payment less a 20% commission (V.6). Copying BTC Anchor cost 100 USD a month (as of 17 Nov 2026). On top come a terminal that runs around the clock and your broker’s costs. How MQL5’s own VPS helps here and what it costs is covered in MQL5 VPS explained.
Expect deviations, too: your broker has different spreads and prices, and every copy is executed with some delay. The shorter the EA holds positions, the stronger the effect.
The check as a list
- Real account, live server, known set file?
- Since when a signal, since when an account, since when on sale?
- Which warnings does MQL5 show?
- Drawdown by balance and by equity side by side
- Maximum deposit load
- Leverage against your own leverage
- Subscribers only as a side note
- Subscription, VPS and broker costs added up
If the signal belongs to an EA from the MQL5 Market, check the demo, reviews and licence next, as described in how to judge an MQL5 Market EA. Every MQL5 EA we grade is in the table of the best MQL5 EAs 2026, every EA in the EA overview, and signal platforms are compared under signal providers. How we weigh evidence is in our methodology. This page is not investment advice.